Disclaimer: This meal was gifted to the reviewer for the purpose of this review and all thoughts and opinions are their own.
Tucked away in the charming hamlet of Mitton, right in the heart of the Ribble Valley lies The Three Fishes, a fabulous foodie heaven led by renowned chef Nigel Haworth. With a real passion for local produce and proper, traditional flavours, this place is all about that farm-to-fork goodness. It had been a long time since our last visit and after browsing the enticing menu online we couldn’t wait to tuck into what promised to be a truly special dining experience.
Nigel’s dedication to locally sourced ingredients is evident in every aspect of the menu, with many seasonal elements harvested directly from the restaurant’s kitchen garden or carefully selected from trusted local suppliers. This commitment ensures that each dish is served at peak freshness, resulting in bold, well-balanced flavours that truly shine. From the finest local producers to the restaurant’s own kitchen garden, every ingredient is chosen with care, and the attention to detail elevates even the simplest of dishes. The menu proudly showcases regional treasures like Mrs. Kirkham’s cheese and Morecambe Bay lobster, celebrating the authentic flavours of Lancashire’s rich culinary heritage.
The menu changes with the seasons, meaning there is always something new to discover. On this occasion, we ate from the Farm-to-Fork Tasting Menu, a carefully curated five-course journey through the best that the local land and sea have to offer. Despite it being a midweek evening, the restaurant maintained a lively yet intimate atmosphere, with just the right level of bustle to create a sense of occasion. Service was impeccable, with the knowledgeable staff providing detailed explanations of each dish and offering personal recommendations, particularly when it came to accompaniments for the pheasant. Small but significant touches—such as a waitress noticing our water needed replenishing without being asked demonstrated a level of attentiveness that is all too rare.
The meal commenced with Nigel’s Lancashire Cheese Bread Rolls, made with the renowned Mrs. Kirkham’s Lancashire Cheese. These warm, pillowy rolls were accompanied by a savoury black pea hummus and a bright, herbaceous parsley pesto, an inspired combination of flavors and textures that set the tone for the meal ahead.
Next came the Baked Wilja Potato, sourced from a local farm and presented with samphire butter, fennel coleslaw, and puffed rice. The contrast of crispy, golden skin against the fluffy interior, drenched in rich butter, was simply divine. It was a masterclass in how to elevate a humble ingredient to something truly memorable.
Now, if I had to pick a standout moment from the evening, it would have to be the Morecambe Bay Lobster Soup. A properly well-executed dish, it had a rich, deep-sea flavour that was further enhanced by a bit of cream and a very sensible amount of chili, just enough to make itself known without being overpowering. The addition of sticky rice, along with decent-sized chunks of lobster and haddock, provided a pleasing contrast in texture. Each spoonful was a rather excellent balance of spice and creaminess, and I must say, this is one of those dishes that stays with you – in a good way, of course.
The Ribble Valley Pheasant Breast arrived as a golden-brown schnitzel, fried in pheasant fat for extra depth of flavour, and served with a fragrant herb butter and a spiced crumb. We opted for the super thick chips and cauliflower as accompaniments, though the unexpected highlight was a delightful serving of pheasant shepherd’s pie. Nigel’s philosophy of using every part of the bird resulted in a deeply satisfying dish, succulent minced pheasant with a sweet, moreish flavour, topped with a cloud-like layer of mashed potato.
For dessert, the Foragers Souffle, a delicate apple and bramble souffle was an absolute triumph. Light and fluffy it melted on the tongue and was served alongside a delicious, brown bread ice cream and crunchy croutons, providing a medley of textures that made each mouthful an absolute pleasure. Just when we thought we had finished, a final surprise arrived: a small Eccles cake, its crisp, flaky pastry encasing plump, juicy currants, providing a perfectly sweet ending to an exceptional meal.
Dining at The Three Fishes is a masterclass in how to celebrate local produce with skill, creativity, and a deep respect for the land. Nigel Haworth has created more than just a restaurant, he has crafted an experience that is both comforting and exciting, traditional yet innovative. This is farm-to-fork dining at its finest, and it’s one I’ll be eager to return to again.
5 courses £39 Wednesday & Thursday and £49 on Friday & Saturdays
To book telephone 01254 826666 or email reservations@thethreefishes.co.uk
The Review Studio 